Would recommend the Firestone winterforce Tire hands down.
It is a long wearing Tire with an aggressive tread suitable for deep snow. But also has ice technology built into the tire for enhance ice traction.
These are by far the worst tires I have ever had. The car slides like it's on snow as soon as the pavement gets wet and makes horrible road noise. It literally sounds like basketballs bouncing every time the car hits a bump. As for durability, the tread is chunking and I've already put 2 plugs in the tires. A stick actually went through the tread, not a nail or screw, an actual stick which is pretty pathetic.
Horrible tires. They slide on dry pavement while getting on and off highways, they are extremely noisy and they are extremely cheaply made. Just an overall junk tire that should never be put on a car but somehow slipped through the cracks and got DoT approval.
These tires are horrible.